In the aftermath of last week’s Tudor vs. Rolex clash, it’s time for another intense Rolex showdown. The spotlight falls on the replica Rolex GMT-Master II “Black and Gray” variants, with last year’s introduction of the 18K yellow gold and Rolesor versions pitted against this year’s stainless steel iteration. Anticipated by many, the steel model steps into the ring, challenging its two-tone counterpart. So, how does it fare against the established dual-tone model? Let’s delve into this head-to-head GMT-Master II face-off.
Watches and Wonders 2024 has concluded, leaving a trail of exciting releases and heated debates in its wake. In our Sunday Morning Showdown series, we bring you the most riveting matchups, and this week, it’s all about the Rolex GMT-Master IIs. Specifically, we’re examining the clash between the two-tone and stainless steel versions featuring the black and gray bezel. While last year’s full-gold and two-tone models garnered praise from fans, the introduction of this year’s steel variant raises intriguing questions. Bearing a striking resemblance to the 2007 GMT-Master II ref. 116710LN, the stainless steel model diverges from its current steel GMT siblings. But does it hold its own in popularity? Let’s dissect this battle.
Last week, in the Sunday Morning Showdown…
Before we dive into this week’s contest, let’s revisit the showdown from last Sunday. The matchup featured the new METAS-certified Black Bay from Tudor squaring off against the reigning champion, the Rolex Submariner ref. 124060. Despite the Tudor Black Bay’s nod to Submariner aesthetics, the results revealed a clear winner, with the Submariner clinching 59% of the votes compared to the Black Bay’s 41%. Opinions in the comments section varied, with some touting the Black Bay as a worthy successor to the Submariner throne, while others staunchly defended the original’s unrivaled status. As anticipation builds for the arrival of the new Black Bay, the evolution of opinions promises to be intriguing. But for now, let’s turn our attention to Thomas and Jorg for their insights into this week’s GMT-Master II showdown.
Jorg: Rolex GMT-Master II ref. 126713GRNR
Allow me to kick off by expressing my enthusiasm for Rolex’s releases last year, which left a lasting impression. From the titanium Yacht-Master to the pair of fake Rolex GMT-Master IIs and the revamped Daytona collection, 2023 delivered a lineup that resonated with me. However, this year’s offerings failed to elicit the same level of excitement, save for the Day-Date 36 with the white dial and the stainless steel GMT-Master II. When it comes to choosing between last year’s Rolesor edition and this year’s stainless steel GMT-Master II “Black and Gray,” the steel and yellow gold ref. 126713GRNR emerges as the clear favorite.
This week’s clash revolves around aesthetics, but it transcends mere colors and materials, evoking an emotional response rooted in nostalgia. Last year’s duo of GMT-Master II models tapped into a vintage sentimentality that resonates with enthusiasts of pre-Cerachrom sports models. Unlike their flashy counterparts, these models exude a subdued elegance reminiscent of Rolex’s bygone era.
Vintage aesthetics for a modern era
While many of Rolex’s sports models have undergone transformations into sleek, eye-catching iterations, last year’s releases offered a glimpse of hope for clone Rolex traditionalists. As Robert-Jan eloquently articulated in his analysis of the two GMT-Master IIs, these models exude a vintage charm that harks back to the era of five-digit references. The allure of this vintage vibe may be difficult to articulate, but it’s palpable to those who appreciate it.
The combination of stainless steel and yellow gold pays homage to the golden age of two-tone replica watches in the 1970s and ’80s. Rolex’s mastery in crafting steel-and-gold watches, exemplified by classics like the GMT-Master 1675/3 and the “Root Beer” 16753, is undeniable. The timeless appeal of this combination is further enhanced by the iconic Jubilee bracelet, which complements the mixed metals with unparalleled elegance. In contrast, the all-steel construction lacks the same impact and fails to evoke the same emotive response.
Thomas: Rolex GMT-Master II ref. 126710GRNR
Thank you, Jorg, for your insightful perspective on the vintage charm of the two-tone 126713GRNR. While I appreciate its appeal, I lean towards a different conclusion. If one seeks the quintessential vintage Rolex experience, the logical choice lies in acquiring a five-digit GMT-Master in two-tone configuration. The inherent charm of these vintage references, coupled with the iconic Jubilee bracelet, encapsulates the essence of Rolex’s heritage.
For those drawn to the modern precision and engineering prowess of Rolex, the stainless steel 126710GRNR offers a compelling alternative. The all-steel construction exudes a sense of contemporary refinement, epitomizing Rolex’s commitment to excellence. While both the 126710GRNR and the vintage 16753 possess unique attributes, the former’s seamless integration of modern technology and design elevates it above its two-tone counterpart.
The gray bezel dilemma
One aspect that unites our contenders is the black and gray bezel. Personally, I find the gray hue reminiscent of primer paint, lacking the sophistication of an all-black bezel. While I share your sentiment, Jorg, regarding the prominence of the gray on the 126713GRNR, I find that it detracts from the cohesive aesthetic of the watch. In contrast, the subdued gray bezel on the 126710GRNR harmonizes with the overall design, accentuating its understated elegance.